Back to the study
Screenplay experiment archive
104 unedited outputs. Search the scripts, or compare models under the same creative direction. Scores are AI judgments, not human verdicts.
All scenes use the same dinner-betrayal premise. Acceptance means the output met the study's automated criteria; it does not guarantee that a human editor would approve it. Download all scripts (JSON)
104 results · Showing 1–12
Claude Opus 5 · Attempt 1Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 89.7/100 · Accepted by study rubricExpand to read script
INT. NEON WOK — BACK BOOTH — NIGHT Two plates of half-eaten noodles. DANIEL pours tea. MAURA'S phone sits face-up beside her chopsticks. DANIEL So the second round of chemo — when does that start? MAURA Tuesday. Maybe Wednesday. Her phone lights. Daniel glances down out of habit. Freezes. DANIEL (reading) "Caught a twelve-pound bass. Your mother says stop sending money, we're not paupers. Love, Dad." MAURA Give me the phone. DANIEL He went fishing. MAURA Daniel. DANIEL Stage three pancreatic, and he went fishing. She reaches. He lifts the phone away, scrolling. DANIEL (CONT'D) Six months of texts. Golf. A cruise. Something about a new gutter. Maura sets down her chopsticks very carefully. MAURA I needed you to stay. DANIEL What? MAURA You had the offer in Denver. You were packing. And I said the thing that made you unpack. Silence. Daniel places the phone face-down between them. DANIEL I turned down Denver. I also gave your father's "treatment fund" eleven thousand dollars. MAURA (quietly) I know. DANIEL Then he's about to get a call. From me. Tonight. He stands, pockets his own phone, and takes hers with him.
Claude Opus 5 · Attempt 2Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 92.7/100 · Accepted by study rubricExpand to read script
INT. RENTED APARTMENT — KITCHEN — NIGHT Two plates of half-eaten pasta. A bottle of wine, mostly gone. DANA refills her glass. MARCUS's phone buzzes face-down beside his fork. MARCUS Your dad texted me. DANA (too fast) He shouldn't be texting. MARCUS He says thanks for the golf clubs. He turns the phone over. Reads. MARCUS (CONT'D) He says he shot an eighty-four Sunday. Dana drinks. Sets the glass down carefully. MARCUS (CONT'D) Stage three, you said. Pancreas. DANA Marcus— MARCUS I gave notice at work. I told them my girlfriend's father was dying, and they let me out of the contract, and I moved here. DANA I know. MARCUS Was there ever a diagnosis? Silence. She picks up her fork, puts it down. DANA You were leaving in March. You had the flight open on your laptop. MARCUS So you invented a tumor. DANA I invented a reason to stay. You needed one. You've never once stayed without one. He stands. Takes his coat off the chair. Stops. MARCUS His birthday's Thursday. DANA Yes. MARCUS I already sent the flowers. (beat) Card says: fight hard. He puts the coat back on the chair. Sits. Picks up his fork. MARCUS (CONT'D) Pour me one.
Kimi K3 · Attempt 1Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 89.0/100 · Accepted by study rubricExpand to read script
INT. APARTMENT DINING ROOM — NIGHT Half-eaten pasta. Two wine glasses. MARCUS, 40s, pushes food around his plate. ELAINE, 40s, tops off her glass. MARCUS I swung by St. Vincent's today. Thought I'd bring your dad some flowers. Elaine's hand stops mid-pour. ELAINE He's being moved. Different facility. MARCUS That's the thing. There's no patient under his name. Not at St. Vincent's. Not anywhere in their system. She sets the bottle down. Carefully. ELAINE They must've made a mistake. MARCUS I called his house, Elaine. He answered. He's in Florida. Golfing. Silence. She looks at her plate, then up — and something in her face shifts. The performance drops. ELAINE Six months. You stayed six extra months because you felt sorry for me. MARCUS I stayed because I loved you. ELAINE You were packing your bags in January. I saw the suitcase. Marcus stands, chair scraping. He grabs his coat — then stops at the door, laughing once, bitter. MARCUS The donations. My mother's necklace. "For his treatments." ELAINE I'll pay it back. MARCUS Keep it. Consider it tuition. He opens the door — and Elaine's phone BUZZES on the table. The screen lights up: "DAD ❤️." She stares at it, then answers, voice instantly bright. ELAINE (into phone) Hi, Daddy. Yes — the check cleared. Marcus, frozen in the doorway, slowly turns back around.
Kimi K3 · Attempt 2Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 84.0/100 · Accepted by study rubricExpand to read script
INT. SMALL APARTMENT KITCHEN - NIGHT A candle flickers between two plates of half-eaten pasta. DANIEL (40s) refills CLAIRE's (30s) wine glass. Warm, easy. DANIEL How's your dad holding up? I keep meaning to ask. CLAIRE Same. Chemo Tuesdays. He hates the Jell-O. DANIEL (laughs, then) I could drive up with you this weekend. Meet him before... you know. It's been a year, Claire. Claire freezes. Fork mid-air. CLAIRE He's not up for visitors. DANIEL One visitor. I'm practically family. He pulls out his phone. DANIEL (CONT'D) Actually — my cousin's an oncologist at Mercy. Which ward is he in? She could look in on him. Silence. Claire sets the fork down. Very carefully. CLAIRE Daniel— DANIEL What ward, Claire? Her eyes don't move. That's the answer. Daniel's face changes — slow, like ice cracking. DANIEL (CONT'D) The donations. The fundraiser I ran at work. Nine thousand dollars. CLAIRE I needed to get out of the lease. The deposit— DANIEL You let me give a toast. About his courage. He stands. Takes his coat. At the door, he turns. DANIEL (CONT'D) I'm calling the office Monday. You can explain where the money went, or the police can. The door shuts. Claire sits alone. Then — she calmly finishes her wine.
GPT-5.6 Sol · Attempt 1Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 90.7/100 · Accepted by study rubricExpand to read script
INT. RESTAURANT — NIGHT Half-eaten pasta cools between DANIEL, 38, and MAYA, 35. Her phone buzzes beside the breadbasket. DANIEL You should check it. The hospital might need you. MAYA They have my number. The phone buzzes again. Daniel glances down. A video notification fills the screen: MAYA’S FATHER, grinning on a sailboat, sprays champagne over a banner reading CANCER-FREE FOR 12 YEARS! Daniel taps it. Silent confetti erupts. DANIEL Twelve years? Maya snatches the phone. MAYA He had a mole removed. DANIEL You said stage four. You said you moved in with him for chemo. MAYA I needed time. DANIEL So you invented terminal cancer? MAYA I tried “I’m overwhelmed.” You sent soup, called therapists, made spreadsheets. Cancer was the only boundary you respected. Daniel absorbs that. Removes a small velvet box from his pocket and sets it beside her plate. Maya stares. MAYA Oh. DANIEL I was going to ask tonight. MAYA Daniel— He opens the box. Inside is a key, not a ring. DANIEL To move in. Maya exhales, almost laughing with relief. Daniel takes back the key. DANIEL Good news. Your father just made a miraculous recovery. He signals for the check.
GPT-5.6 Sol · Attempt 2Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 84.7/100 · Accepted by study rubricExpand to read script
INT. NEIGHBORHOOD BISTRO — NIGHT Half-eaten steaks cool between ELI, 38, and NORA, 36. Nora’s phone buzzes beside her wineglass. The lock screen displays a message from DAD: STOP TELLING PEOPLE I HAVE CANCER. CALL ME. Eli reads it. Nora flips the phone facedown. ELI What does that mean? NORA He’s confused. The medication— ELI You said he refused treatment. NORA Eli— He takes a folded bank receipt from his jacket and smooths it beside her plate. ELI I emptied my savings this morning. Forty-two thousand dollars. For his surgery. Nora stares at the receipt. NORA I was going to tell you. ELI Before or after I gave you the check? NORA There is no surgery. ELI Is there even cancer? She shakes her head. ELI Then what’s the money for? Nora reaches into her purse and sets down an ultrasound image. NORA The clinic. Three rounds of IVF. I knew you’d say we couldn’t afford it. Eli studies the grainy shape. ELI We agreed to stop trying. NORA I didn’t. A long beat. Eli takes out his phone and taps the screen. NORA What are you doing? ELI Cancelling the check. NORA You can’t. ELI Why? Nora places a protective hand over the ultrasound. NORA Because I already deposited it. Her phone buzzes again: TRANSFER COMPLETE.
DeepSeek V4 Pro 0813 · Attempt 1Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 83.7/100 · Accepted by study rubricExpand to read script
INT. UPSCALE RESTAURANT - NIGHT A quiet corner booth. LEO (40s), tie loosened, saws through a steak. Across from him, MAYA (40s) nurses a glass of red wine, her salad untouched. LEO You barely touched your food. MAYA I’m not very hungry. LEO Still thinking about your dad? Maya nods. Leo reaches across the table, covers her hand. LEO (CONT'D) The treatment’s going to work. MAYA You don’t know that. LEO I know you’re scared. But my company’s flying in the oncologist from Sloan Kettering next week. Maya’s eyes widen, then drop. MAYA You didn’t have to do that. LEO Of course I did. He pulls out his phone, holds it up, and shows her a confirmation email. LEO (CONT'D) Already booked it. Maya glances at the screen. Her face freezes. MAYA Leo... when did you send this? LEO Two days ago. Why? Maya’s lips part, then press together. She withdraws her hand, picks up her wine, and drains it in one long swallow. MAYA I need to tell you something. Leo’s brow furrows. He puts his phone face-down on the white tablecloth. LEO What’s going on? MAYA My father doesn’t have cancer. Leo blinks. A fork hovers, then lowers. LEO What? MAYA There’s no tumor. No oncologist. LEO The hospitals... the crying calls... MAYA The crying was real. That’s me, being a terrible person. Leo stares at the half-eaten steak. He sets the fork down with a soft finality. LEO So, what is it? Another guy? A divorce lawyer? MAYA Worse. She looks up; tears arrow down her cheeks. MAYA (CONT'D) I’m me. And you’re you. And I don’t know how to leave someone this good. Leo studies her, then slouches back against the leather booth. LEO You don’t have to leave. Just stop lying. MAYA I tried. You don’t listen. The check arrives. Neither of them reaches for it.
DeepSeek V4 Pro 0813 · Attempt 2Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 79.7/100 · Accepted by study rubricExpand to read script
INT. APARTMENT DINING ROOM - NIGHT A modest table set for two. Half-eaten plates. A bottle of red wine, nearly empty. MARK, 40s, twirls pasta. LENA, 30s, watches him. LENA You’re quiet. MARK Long day. LENA Tell me about it. Beat. MARK I called your dad’s office today. Wanted to send flowers. Lena’s hand stops mid-reach for her glass. MARK (CONT'D) His assistant answered. Said he’s in Singapore. Closing a deal. LENA Mark— MARK Said he’s been there three weeks. Full health. LENA I can explain. MARK You told me he had cancer. Stage three. LENA I know what I said. MARK Why? LENA Because you were leaving. Mark stares. LENA (CONT'D) You had one foot out the door. I needed you to stay. MARK So you killed your father. LENA I bought time. Mark pushes his plate away. Stands. MARK Time for what? LENA For you to remember why you loved me. Mark picks up his keys. MARK I don’t. He walks out. Lena sits alone. She picks up her fork. Takes a bite. Chews.
Nemotron 3 Ultra · Attempt 1Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 81.3/100 · Accepted by study rubricExpand to read script
INT. RESTAURANT - NIGHT MARK (30s) cuts his steak. LENA (30s) pushes risotto around her plate. A half-empty bottle of red breathes between them. MARK How’s he holding up? Lena doesn’t look up. LENA Good days, bad days. Mostly bad now. MARK (Chews, swallows) The new immunotherapy — did they start it? LENA (Flat) Next week. If his blood counts recover. Mark nods, signaling a passing waiter for the check. He pulls out his phone, taps a contact: "Mom." Puts it to his ear. MARK (Into phone) Hey, Ma. Yeah, dinner was... listen, Lena’s dad. The one with the lymphoma? You still talk to Betty from the oncology desk at St. Luke’s? He listens, fork frozen mid-air. Lena picks up her water glass. Her knuckles whiten. MARK (Into phone) Right. Right. No, just... thanks. He hangs up. Sets the phone face-down. Stares at Lena. MARK Betty retired. Two years ago. St. Luke’s oncology wing burned down in ’21. They moved to Mercy General. Lena’s thumb traces the stem of her glass. She sets it down. Perfectly centered. LENA The risotto’s cold. She stands, drops cash on the table, and walks out. Mark sits alone with two entrees and a lie he can’t return.
Nemotron 3 Ultra · Attempt 2Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 81.7/100 · Accepted by study rubricExpand to read script
INT. RESTAURANT - NIGHT Clinking silverware. Half-eaten entrees. MARK (40s) watches LENA (40s) push fish around her plate. MARK How's your dad? The new treatment? Lena pauses, fork mid-air. LENA Good. Good. They're... optimistic. MARK That's great. Really. He signals the waiter for the check. Pulls out his phone, screen lighting up with a notification. He freezes. INSERT - PHONE SCREEN: A photo post from "Marie Calloway." Lena, her father, and a golden retriever on a golf course. Caption: "Dad crushing it at 18 holes today! #remission #luckydog" Timestamp: 20 minutes ago. Mark stares at the screen. Then at Lena. She cuts a bite of fish, chews carefully. MARK (quietly) He's golfing. Lena stops chewing. LENA What? MARK Marie posted a photo. Twenty minutes ago. Your dad. Eighteen holes. Lena swallows. Sets her fork down. The mask doesn't slip -- it calcifies. LENA Oh. That's... he has good days. MARK Good days don't cure stage four pancreatic cancer, Lena. A beat. She reaches for her water glass. Her hand doesn't shake. LENA Then I guess it's a miracle. Pass the salt?
Gemini 3.7 Flash · Attempt 1Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 80.7/100 · Accepted by study rubricExpand to read script
INT. BISTRO - NIGHT Plates of half-eaten pasta sit between MARK (30s) and ELENA (30s). Mark slides a thick manila folder across the linen tablecloth. MARK Dr. Alvarez agreed to take him. Stage four protocol, starting Monday. Elena stares at the medical files, her fork suspended in mid-air. ELENA Mark... you didn't have to call him. MARK He’s family. If the chemo isn't shrinking the tumor, we need a specialist. Elena's phone lights up on the table. A text notification previews: *Dad: Just finished 18 holes in the sun! Booking the Cabo flights now, kiddo.* Mark reads the screen. The warmth instantly vanishes from his eyes. MARK (CONT'D) Eighteen holes? ELENA (reaching for the phone) He... he has good days. MARK You said he was admitted to hospice care in Seattle this morning. Elena pulls her hand back. Her silence answers him. MARK (CONT'D) Why? ELENA You were packing your bags last week, Mark. You were going to leave me. Mark stares at her. He calmly pulls the medical folder back, drops a hundred-dollar bill onto his plate, and stands up. MARK Now I am
Gemini 3.7 Flash · Attempt 2Bare prompt — no referenceAI rubric 58.0/100 · Below study acceptance criteriaExpand to read script
INT. BISTRO - NIGHT Half-eaten pasta sits between MARK (30s) and ELENA (30s). Mark slides a folded check across the white tablecloth. MARK Ten thousand. For his hospice care. You shouldn't carry this alone. Elena stares at the paper